Sunday, 11 December 2011

Frank Lloyd Wright As An Influence On Rudolph Schindler

Frank Lloyd Wright traveled to Japan due to his fascination with ukiyo-e woodblock prints in 1905. During his stay he was influenced by Japanese architecture, evident in his usage of long and low windows to allow for a connection from the interior to the outside. He proceeded to work on the Imperial Hotel in Tokyo, Japan, later on in his career in 1923 with Rudolph Schindler.


Imperial Hotel, Tokyo, Japan




 
Rudolph Schindler was subsequently influenced by Frank Lloyd Wright's eastern take on architecture, as is evident in his modern homes such as the Schindler Chase where window frames and walls are reminiscent of Japanese style sliding doors.





Schindler Chase House, Los Angeles

Schindler's Early Solo Works













Lovell Beach House (1922-1926)














El Pueblo Ribera Court (1923)










How House (1925)




















Wolfe House (1928)















Rodriguez House (1942)
















Roth House (1945)










Anqi Zhang, Dec 11, 2011

Diagrams of the Schindler- Chase House










Dee Wang, Dec, 11, 2011.

Saturday, 10 December 2011

Weather/Climate Conditions of Los Angeles


Los angeles is the 2nd largest city in the United States, next to New York. It has a Sub-tropical Mediterranean climate; a region of hot and dry climate. It receives approximately 16~20 inches of rain annually, and the temperatures could go up to as high as 45 degrees Celsius.
Using this climate to his advantage, Schindler utilized the tilt-slab construction method in the absence of frequent precipitation and cold weather. Additionally, in the design of the Shindler-Chase House itself, it could be seen that the intimate and engaging relationship between the outside and the inside is only made possible thanks to the tolerating weather.

The span between the day and night temperature is not too insignificant like that of a tropical forest. However, the temperature is still well above freezing point at night, whereas during the day it is hot.



The precipitation throughout the year in Los Angeles is minuscule; it receives around 16~20 inches and around 8 inches during the dry seasons. Additionally, the climate is consistently hot or moderate, regardless of different seasons. During the winter it is cool, whereas in the summer it can be scorching hot.



Street in Los Angeles


Vegetation requires minimal moisture

The landscape is composed of both flatland and hills.







Howard Won, Dec 11, 2011

Famous Architects in Los Angeles and Their Influence on Schindler



Irving Gill (1870-1936)

The work of Irving Gill would continue to influence their disciples Rudolph Schindler and Richard Neutra. From their professional beginnings until the end of their lives, both of the younger men were conscious of their debts to Irving Gill.

He argued " we must build our house simple, plain and substantial as a boulder, then leave the ornamentation of it to Nature, who will tone it with lichens, chisel it with stroms, make it gracious and friendly with vines and flower shadows as she does the stone in the meadow."

Dodge House (1914-1916)

- Schindler was an admirer of Irving Gill. The schindler was pleased to build their own house so near the great Dodge house located within a few blocks of each other.

- Schindle borrowed aspects of Gill's tilt-slab construction technique, in which concrete slabs were poured to harden in molds on the round, then tilted upright and linked with narrow, glazed interstices to from the structure's outside walls.


Frank Lloyd Wright

Though Frank Lloyd Wright once referred to Southern California as a “desert of shallow effects,” his remarkable cluster of built and unbuilt Los Angeles projects (1919- 1924) attests to the region’s strong hold upon him.
-Schindler managed Wright’s office during his several long absences in Japan and Californina: Typical of Schindler’s designs in Wright’s absence was an unbuilt project for the Shampay house (1919)- its ownership has been discussed for the last few years. -
He referred to the Los Angeles work as his California Romanza – “being frankly on holiday.” More “expressionistic” than his early, rational Prairie style, yet more controlled than the jagged flamboyance of his later years, Wright’s work of the middle period drew heavily from the forms of pre-Columbian Mexico and the American Southwest.

Schindler’s impression to Wright:
While most architecture was, and would continue to be, about space as well as structure, Schindler and Wright were among the earliest to articulate the difference verbally with an emphasis on the former… It was chiefly in Wright’s Prairie period, Schindler believed, that this was most obvious, whereas in such later work as the Imperial Hotel and the Barnsdall house he would “become sculptural.” In Japan and California, Schindler observed ambivalently, Wright
sought “to weave his buildings into the character of the locality through sculptural forms.”


Imperial Hotel in Tokyo (1915-1919)
With his epochal Imperial Hotel, Wright’s California designs of the early 1920s comprise the essence of his undervalued “middle period,” a body of work temporally situated between the acclaimed architecture of his Prairie years (ca. 1893-1914) and that of his celebrated late decades (ca. 1932 – 1959).

Neutra


-From the time of their births in late-nineteenth-century Vienna through the launching of their careers in America, the lives and the work of Schindler and Neutra would remain intertwined. Yet from the beginning there were also significant differences…

- In early February 1925, when the Neutras joined the Schindler's at Kings Road, a new era began for the two young architects and for California modernist architecture. However similar their Viennese origins, temperamental differences and historical contingencies of timing and circumstance had caused their journeys to take different forms.

- The strongest confirmation of Neutra's growing international reputation and of Schindler's correspondingly ambiguous standing was Neutra's inclusion in, and Schindler's exclusion from, the 1932 "Modern Architecture" exhibition at New York's Museum of Modern Art.


Lovell Health house - Neutra had a same client to Schindler, Philip and Leah Lovell.

- Neutra designed "Lovell Health house" which is larger than Schindler's "Lovel Beach house."
-turning point in Neutra's career.
-Museum director Alfred Barr's principles :
"The new architect thinks in terms of volume as apposed to mass and solidity."
"Beauty in the new style depends upon technically perfect use of materials whether metal, wood, glass or concrete; upon the fineness of proportions in units such as doors and windows and in the relationships between these and the whole design."
>Neutra's Lovell Health epitomized these principles while Schindler's Lovell Beach House embodied them only partially.









Lovell Beach House (1926) Lovell Health House (1928)


Otto Wagner (1841- 1918)
The Viennese architects most crucial to the work and the world view of Schindler and Neutra were Otto Wagner and Adolf Loos, both of whom were teachers of Schindler. Neutra, five years younger, was not able to study with Wagner vefore his retirement from the Imperial Academy of Art, but he learned from his example as a modernist pathbreaker. Like Schindler, Neutra thrived in Loos’s informal, less institutional, “Bauschule” salon…
Wagner’s professorship at the Academy of Fine Arts included the establishment of his own design studio and the teaching of master classes, the so-called Wagnerschule, to which only a few students were admitted each year and produced the most creative designers of the first half of the twentieth-century including R.M. Schindler.

Postal Saving Bank (1905)

Aside from the modular, steel-framed Stadtbahn stations of the 1890s, the building of Wagner’s that most interested Schindler and Neutra was his Postal Savings Bank, the first modern building to be granted a place of honor on the architecturally historicist Ringstrasse. Near the front entrance, flanked by offices on three sides, stands the double-height, steel and glass banking room- the most significant and spectacular feature of the building. The sophisticate furniture and fixtures, all designed by Wagner, combine Machine Age metaphor with functional suitability. The building epitomized the Germanic concept of the Gesamtkunstwerk, the layered and integrated total work of art, a concept that would influence Schindler and Nuetra, as it had earlier inspired their American mentor, Frank Lloyd Wright.




Adolf Loos
-Since Wagner and most of his students still sanctioned systems of organically integrated architectural ornament, it remained for another Viennese architect, Adolf Loos, to provide the crucial counterpoint in his polemical assertion that ornament was a "crime."

-Two of these, Schindler and Neutra, would learn from Loos in revealingly different ways – Schindler primarily from the Raumplan complexity of his architectural interiors, Neutra primarily from the stark simplicity of his surfaces.

Interior of Villa Muller















Soo Jung Woo & Fysal Amirzada, Dec 11, 2011

A Quotation From Rudolph Schindler


Schindler's own description of the house:
Each room in the house represents a variation on the constructive architectural theme. This theme corresponds to the principle requirements for protecting a tent: a protected back, an open front, an open fireplace and a roof. Each room has a concrete wall at the rear and a large front opening onto the garden with sliding doors. The shape of the rooms and their relationship to the patios and various roof levels creates a totally new spatial concept between the interior and the garden.
Dee Wang, Dec 10, 2011

Construction


Some inspirations:



Irving John Gill
-Irving Gill was an American architect who practiced in California.
-He utilized early tilt-slab construction method.
-his concepts included:
-interiors concerned with removing most unnecessary detailing, for reasons of economy and hygiene.
-minimal or flush moldings.
-simple or no fireplace mantles.





















Cossitt House

The Dodge House



Trip to the National Yosemite Park
-During their camping trip to the Yosemite Park, Schindler was inspired by the simplicity of the necessary tools of survival.
-The concept of "existence minimum."
-excluding unnecessary and extra components.



















Program/Conceptual Design
-The home had no conventional kitchen, dining room and living room.
-It was a place of residence and work for two young families.
-The form contained two interconnected apartments, having the shape of the letter “L.”
-It also consisted of two studios and an interconnected utility room, which housed a kitchen, laundry, sewing room and pantry.
-The concept of separate studios represented his interpretation of the family as a group of independent individuals with common goals.
-The studio was universal space; it could function differently to meet the inhabitant’s need.
-precedent: Wright’s Taliesin.
-It also included a guest room with it's own kitchen and bathroom.
-on the roof each unit contained a terrace-basket, which included rain canvas.
-The idea of opposition between concrete walls and glass screens was the direct result of the relationship between the building and the site. (A suburban rectangular parcel bordered by neighbors on three sides and open to the street on the fourth.
-the house was set back in the middle of the lot, but extended almost to the property line on the sides.
-The main objective view was to: open the building to light, views, and the gardens while providing complete privacy for the occupants.
-The building plan was a pinwheel of three L-shaped arms that pivoted around a double fireplace.
-The visual axe defined the space and established an unbroken connection between interior and exterior.
-Schindler eliminated references to doors, windows, and walls, transforming the one-story structure into a composition of transparent and solid vertical planes bounded by two horizontal planes (the flat roof and the concrete slab).
-a building that was an expression of the new art of the century: geometric abstraction.
-Conception of the entire plot as the architectural field. (dispensing with a figure-ground relationship and thus giving equal weight to building and landscape)
-The living areas – the building, three courtyards, guest terrace, and driveway
–sit several feet above the ground plane on a raised surface, as if on a podium.
-Natural topography of the site: slopes down to the southwest.
-Schindler extended his spatial exploration into the surroundings by treating the gardens with a geometric precision.
-The landscape of the home could be considered in hierarchical order, from mass to dematerialized screen: four large concrete blocks (the chimneys); seven blocks, equally massive, of giant bamboo; bamboo hedges and concrete walls; wallboard in redwood framing; privet hedges; high grass; canvas panels; and large planes of glass.
-Gardens continued the same aesthetic themes as expressed in the house, but with a greater sense of liberation.
-Overlapping geometric planes created a free plan.

Progress
-Permission to build the house was temporary, which means the local authorities could halt the construction process at any time.
-the construction began in November 1921.
-the excavation and pouring of the floor slabs began on February 1922.
-the tilt-up walls are fabricated and cast by March 19, 1922.
-the walls were raised in place using a tripod with a block and a tackle, starting with the garage, between March 28 and April 24.
-the house was completed in May 1922.
-Cost: $12,550 (divided into the following sub categories)
  • Lot: $2,750
  • Construction (Labor and materials): $7,000
  • Architect’s supervision: $500
  • Contractor’s profit: $1,000
  • Architect’s fee: $800
  • Owner’s labor: $500



Process
-materials were industrial products (unfinished state and natural colour): concrete, glass, a machine-manufactured wallboard, machine-milled redwood, copper, and canvas.
-the house was built on a flat concrete slab (foundation and the final floor). This eliminated the need for expensive excavation and construction of the basement.
-the tilt-up panels were fabricated on site by pouring concrete into wood forms.
-membranes, such as soft soap, craft paper, and burlap were used to prevent adhesion to the slab.
-panels were then lifted into place using a tripod with a block and tackle.
-panels of neutral cage of redwood were erected around the concrete and fitted with glass or insul
ate panels.
-the concrete was smooth and grey, whereas the glass was both clear and milky white (created through sandblasting).
-each studio was screened from the garden by three translucent off-white canvas panels.
-The house had hard sheltering walls at the back, whereas at the front it had a softer permeable screen.
-rooms had concrete walls on three sides and sliding glass to the outdoors.


1. Fabrication of the tilt-up panels.


2. Panels are lifted in place.

3. Panels of neutral cage of redwood are erected.

4. Wood frames are installed for the roof.


Howard Won, December 10, 2011

Thursday, 8 December 2011

Modern Homes Built After The Schindler- Chace House

 The first map describes how notable modern homes have spread out east after the SCH was built while still remaining at the base of the hills around Hollywood and Los Feliz. It is also important to mention the general lack of modern homes being built in the later 30's due to the great depression.
The second map describes how modern homes were concentrated in the general Los Angeles area after the SCH was built, and later expanded north and south into San Francisco and San Diego.

Fysal Amirzada, December 8, 2011

Map of L.A Development (1900-1920)




From top to bottom:  
 
          1. 1900 downtown area
2. 1900-1905, Highland Park and South Los Angeles, expanding around downtown
3. 1905-1910, Harbor Gateway, San Pedro and Wilmington, developing towards South
4. 1910-1915, City of Hollywood and Part of Los Feliz
5. 1915-1920, San Fernando Valley, developing towards northwest
Di Wang, Dec 8, 2011